Home / Medical News / E-Cigs Can Help Smokers Quit, But Heart Assoc. Still Worries About Youths

E-Cigs Can Help Smokers Quit, But Heart Assoc. Still Worries About Youths

e-cigaretteBy Alan Lyndon

E-cigs are booming and more research and regulation is needed — quickly — before a new generation becomes addicted or potentially harmed, according to a new policy statement issued by the American Heart Association (AHA).

“We are fiercely committed to preventing the tobacco industry from addicting another generation of smokers,” said Nancy Brown, CEO of the AHA.

Sales of electronic cigarettes are increasing at a much faster rate than traditional smokes.  The e-cig industry is on pace to reach $10 billion in sales by 2017, which would surpass conventional cigarette sales.

Much of the success is due to the marketing of e-cigs to youths through television, social media, and web ads.  “Many of these advertisements have themes that promote rebelliousness and glamorize e-cigarette use, which conveys the message to youth that e-cigarette use is fun, socially acceptable, and desirable,” said the authors of the statement appearing in the journal Circulation.” Such marketing practices are likely to recruit a new generation of nicotine addicts.”

There are over 400 brands and 7,000 flavors of e-cigs on the market.  Adolescents consider these a high tech, accessible alternative to traditional cigarettes.  According to a recent study in JAMA Pediatrics, “use of e-cigarettes does not discourage, and may encourage, conventional cigarette use among US adolescents.”

However, on the other side of the aisle, electronic cigarettes also present an opportunity to help current smokers quit.  The AHA wants to improve research on electronic cigarettes to better determine health effects and usage as a cessation option. “There is not yet enough evidence for clinicians to counsel their patients who are using combustible tobacco products to use e-cigarettes as a primary cessation aid,” said the heart association. “Current evidence suggests at best a modest effect on cessation, likely equal to or slightly better than that of nicotine patches without behavioral support.”

But doctors should consider e-cigs as a viable alternative for their patients in some situations. “If they fail to produce the goal of eliminating tobacco use, e-cigarettes should be tried,” Elliott Antman, MD, cardiologist at Brigham and Women’s Hospital in Boston, Mass., and president of the American Heart Association told MedPage Today. “There should be a quit date established between the patient and clinician, ultimately moving toward an end goal of being completely free of tobacco.”

“Public health officials have an ethical duty to truthfully inform smokers and vapers that e-cigs are far less hazardous alternatives to cigarettes,” Bill Godshall, Executive Director of Smokefree Pennsylvania, recently told Physicians News.

Following are the American Heart Association’s recommendation to doctors for clinical guidance regarding electronic cigarettes:

  • E-cigarette use should be included in tobacco screening questions that are part of every health examination.
  • Clinicians should be educated about e-cigarettes and should be prepared to counsel their patients regarding comprehensive tobacco cessation strategies. Patients should be separated into 3 treatment categories based on their tobacco/e-cigarette use status133:
  1. Tobacco product users who are willing to quit should receive intervention to help them quit
  2. Tobacco product users unwilling to quit at the time should receive interventions to increase their motivation to quit
  3. Those who recently quit using tobacco products should be provided relapse prevention treatment
  • There is not yet enough evidence for clinicians to counsel their patients who are using tobacco products to use e-cigarettes as a primary cessation aid.
  • If a patient has failed initial treatment, has been intolerant to or refuses to use conventional smoking cessation medication, and wishes to use e-cigarettes to aid quitting, it is reasonable to support the attempt. However, patients should be informed that although e-cigarette aerosol is likely to be much less toxic than cigarette smoking, the products are unregulated, may contain low levels of toxic chemicals, and have not been proven to be effective as cessation devices.
  • In the absence of long-term safety studies of e-cigarette use, it may be appropriate to advise the patient to consider setting a quit date for their e-cigarette use and not to plan to use it indefinitely (unless needed to prevent relapse to cigarettes).
  • It is also important to stress that patients should quit smoking cigarettes entirely as soon as possible, because continued cigarette smoking, even at reduced levels, continues to impose tobacco-induced health risks.
  • For patients with existing CVD or stroke, or at risk of a CVD event, intensive cessation counseling and pharmacotherapy should be offered as soon as possible.

This Physicians News story can be republished for free. See details
(Photo by Terry Ozon via Flickr)


  1. The subject line in my case should read: Are e-cigs an alternative to a nicotine addict. Smoked for 50+ years consuming around 1 pack per day and suffered the results of said addiction. Too many to list. Over years tried patches, gum, hypnosis, cold turkey, counseling, prescribed nasty drugs, 2 weeks of self imposed isolation in the woods, religious commitment, nothing helped. I know I am a nicotine addict who likes to blow smoke. That’s it in a nutshell. I’ve seen and heard of e-cigs, thought they were bull. Friend came by smoking one – said he hasn’t felt the urge for cigs for 6 months. Tried one at a e-cig store and immediately found that the level of nicotine satisfied me along with the motion and mechanics of blowing smoke from my penny whistle, as I call it. I have never looked back over 5 months I’ve used an e-cig. Stopped hacking, coughing almost immediately. Mentally and physically I feel much better. Family ecstatic. Absolutely viable nicotine-addict alternative. American tobacco companies got to be taking a hit, along with drug companies making all the assorted stop smoking doohickies. Vaping works for this nicotine junkie. From about 600 additives in a manufactured cigarette(per Wikipedia) I’m down to 4, PG, VG, nicotine liquid, and a flavoring. Studies notwithstanding, empirically I know that I feel a heck of a lot better. I am totally aware I am still a nicotine addict. Totally agree that e-cigs be kept from under 18 crowd. No use starting a yet undetermined deleterious addiction because of e-cig having less dangerous additives than cigarettes. I wish I never toked the first butt over 50 years ago – I wouldn’t be writing this blurb now. Should have learned the saxophone instead. Happy vaping and BETTER health to all you FORMER short and long termers, tobacco-product dyed-in-the-wool junkies.

  2. How are ecigs different than gum or patches other than people enjoy them. I smoked 2 packs a day and tried everything to quit. With the ecigs I have already reduced the nicotine amount twice and about to start the third reduction. I no longer smoke cigarettes. Please quit trying to control peoples lives and let us enjoy the time we have here.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.